Top Mistakes Homeowners Make When Selecting Tile (And How to Avoid Them)

Tile is one of those decisions that feels simple until you are standing in a finished room wishing you had chosen differently. The pattern is busier than you expected, the white reads creamier at home, or the floor feels slick the moment it gets wet. At Design Surfaces, we see these regrets all the time, and they are almost always avoidable. For Cleveland homeowners planning a kitchen, bath, mudroom, or fireplace upgrade, knowing the common tile pitfalls upfront helps you choose with confidence and end up with a space that looks great and lives even better.

Mistake 1: Choosing Tile Based on a Tiny Sample

A two inch square in a showroom cannot show you how tile will feel across an entire wall or floor. Color, pattern scale, and sheen all change when the surface repeats.

How to avoid it:

• View full boards or installed displays whenever possible
• Ask to see multiple pieces from the same run to spot variation
• If it is a patterned tile, step back at least six feet and imagine the repeat

At Design Surfaces, our Westlake showroom lets you compare large boards and real room vignettes so you can see the true impact before you buy.

Mistake 2: Ignoring Undertones and Lighting

Cleveland homes get a wide range of light depending on season, window direction, and bulb temperature. A gray tile can pull blue in morning light, and a white tile can look beige under warm LEDs.

How to avoid it:

• Bring samples home and view them in your own space
• Check the tile in morning, afternoon, and nighttime lighting
• Hold it next to cabinets, paint, and countertops to confirm undertones

Key insight: If a tile only looks good in one lighting condition, it is not the right long term choice.

Mistake 3: Picking Floor Tile Without Checking Slip Resistance

Glossy floors can be beautiful, but in bathrooms, laundry rooms, and entries, they can become a daily hazard. This is especially important during Cleveland winters when water and snow get tracked inside.

How to avoid it:

• Look for a suitable DCOF rating for wet areas
• Choose a textured finish for bathrooms and mudrooms
• Save polished or high gloss tile for walls and backsplashes

If you love the look of polished tile, ask our team about safer finishes that deliver the same elegance.

Mistake 4: Forgetting About Grout Color and Size

Grout is not a background detail. It is part of the design. The wrong grout color can make a tile look grid like, dated, or too high contrast. Grout width can also change the entire visual rhythm.

How to avoid it:

• Decide grout color early, not after tile is chosen
• Use light grout for a seamless look and darker grout for definition
• Consider smaller grout lines for large format porcelain to feel more slab like

At Design Surfaces, we help you test grout pairings with your tile so you can see the final look before installation.

Mistake 5: Overlooking Maintenance Needs

Some tiles are forgiving and some are high attention. For example, light natural stone on a kitchen floor may stain faster than porcelain, and textured tile can hold onto grime around sinks or showers.

How to avoid it:

• Ask how the tile should be cleaned and sealed
• Choose porcelain for high traffic floors and workhorse areas
• If you want natural stone, plan for sealing and gentle cleaners

Tile should fit your lifestyle, not just your Pinterest board.

Mistake 6: Choosing Wall Tile That Fights the Countertop

Backsplashes and shower walls are often chosen in isolation, but they should work with your stone surfaces. A countertop with dramatic movement can clash with a busy tile, while a simple quartz slab may need a more dimensional tile to avoid feeling flat.

How to avoid it:

• If your countertop is bold, choose a quieter tile
• If your countertop is subtle, add personality with shape or pattern
• Bring countertop samples when choosing tile, or choose both together

This is one reason Cleveland homeowners love shopping tile and countertops in one place. Design Surfaces makes it easy to build a coordinated palette.

Mistake 7: Getting the Scale Wrong for the Room

Large tile can make a small bathroom feel bigger, but in some layouts it can also look awkward if cuts are too tight. Small mosaic tile adds texture, but can look chaotic over a large wall.

How to avoid it:

• Use large format tile on floors or big shower walls for a spacious feel
• Save mosaics for niches, accents, or smaller zones
• Think about your grout grid and where cuts will land

Key insight: Scale should match the space and the sightlines, not just current trends.

Mistake 8: Not Considering Where Tile Starts and Stops

Tile edges and transitions are where good remodels look polished or unfinished. A backsplash height that stops too low can feel dated. A shower tile line that ends at an odd height can disrupt the whole room.

How to avoid it:

• Plan tile height and termination lines before ordering
• Consider full height backsplashes for a clean, custom look
• Use trim pieces or Schluter style edges for crisp transitions

Our Design Surfaces team can help you map out the layout so the final install looks intentional from every angle.

Mistake 9: Buying Tile Without Ordering Extra

Even with careful planning, there are always cuts, breakage, and future repairs to think about. If a tile is discontinued later, matching it can be impossible.

How to avoid it:

• Order 10 to 15 percent extra for most projects
• Order a bit more for patterned or directional tile
• Store leftovers in a dry, labeled box for future use

Mistake 10: Skipping Expert Guidance

Tile is a design choice, but it is also a technical material. Finish, absorption, grout compatibility, and installation requirements can vary widely. Online shopping rarely catches these details.

How to avoid it:

• Work with a showroom team that understands tile performance
• Ask questions about where a tile should and should not be used
• Choose a supplier who can coordinate tile with your stone surfaces

Design Surfaces does this every day, serving homeowners, designers, and contractors across Cleveland who want high end results without high stress.

Choose Tile Confidently at Design Surfaces

The best tile choices come from seeing materials in person, understanding how they behave, and planning them alongside your countertops and finishes. At Design Surfaces, we help Cleveland homeowners avoid costly mistakes by pairing real world guidance with a curated selection of porcelain, ceramic, marble, quartzite, mosaics, and large format styles. If you are planning a remodel, visit our Westlake showroom to explore tile collections up close, compare them under realistic lighting, and get expert help building a space you will love for years.

​​Call: 440.899.9900 • Contact: Submit a Request • Email: info@designsurfaces.com

‍