Contact info +

The Top 10 Countertop Mistakes Cleveland Homeowners Make, According to Design Surfaces

November 19, 2025

Choosing new countertops should feel exciting. Yet many homeowners across Cleveland end up overwhelmed long before installation day arrives. Sometimes the wrong material gets chosen. Other times the right questions never get asked. At Design Surfaces, serving homeowners, designers, and contractors across Cleveland, we see the same avoidable mistakes again and again. Understanding these pitfalls makes the entire process smoother and ensures your final result looks incredible, performs beautifully, and feels tailored to the way you live.

Below are the top mistakes to avoid, along with expert guidance to help you choose surfaces that elevate your home for years to come.

1. Relying Too Much on Internet Opinions

This is easily the number one mistake. Homeowners arrive convinced they already know which material is best because of something they read online. The problem is that countertop advice is never one size fits all.

Online myths do not account for your lifestyle, your home, or Cleveland’s climate.

A blogger might say marble stains too easily, but a well-sealed marble countertop often performs beautifully. Another might call granite outdated, even though high-end homes in Northeast Ohio continue to use granite for its timeless appeal.

Trust research, but let the experts at Design Surfaces help interpret it for your situation.

2. Ignoring Your Actual Lifestyle

Many homeowners fall in love with a surface for its look, then discover later that it does not fit how they use their kitchen.

Ask yourself:

  • Do you cook daily?
  • Do you host often?
  • Do kids help prep food in your kitchen?
  • Do you want extremely low maintenance?

The right countertop matches your life, not someone else’s.

Quartz and granite often suit busy families. Marble suits homeowners who value elegance and are comfortable with simple care routines.

3. Assuming Quartz Is Completely Maintenance Free

Quartz is durable, but it is not invincible. It can discolor with high heat, scratch when treated carelessly, and fade with intense sunlight.

Every material has strengths and limitations. Knowing them leads to long-lasting satisfaction.

4. Overlooking the Importance of Sealing and Care

Natural stones like marble and granite require periodic sealing. Many homeowners underestimate this step and then worry about staining later.

Sealing is simple, fast, and hugely beneficial.

A few minutes of annual maintenance protects your investment for decades.

5. Choosing Based Only on Trends

A trendy countertop can look great today but feel dated in a few years. It is better to choose something that complements your cabinetry, flooring, and long-term design vision.

Classic finishes and thoughtful color palettes age far better than trend-driven choices.

6. Skipping the Lifestyle-Based Material Comparison

Every material offers unique benefits.

Choosing without comparing leads to regrets.

At Design Surfaces, we encourage homeowners to compare materials side by side so they can feel the textures, examine the movement, and understand the long-term maintenance requirements.

7. Forgetting to View the Full Slab

Samples are helpful, but they do not show full veining, movement, or color variation.

No two natural slabs are identical, and even quartz patterns can feel different when seen at full scale.

Seeing the full slab ensures there are no surprises on installation day.

8. Overlooking Edge Profiles and Finishes

Edges and finishes dramatically impact the final look of your space, yet many homeowners choose them at the last minute without understanding their effect.

Common finishes include:

  • Polished
  • Honed
  • Leathered

Popular edges include:

  • Eased
  • Bullnose
  • Ogee
  • Waterfall

A refined finish or edge profile can elevate even a simple countertop into a custom design centerpiece.

9. Not Considering Overall Design Cohesion

A countertop is not an isolated surface. It must complement your cabinetry, flooring, backsplash tile, appliances, and even natural lighting.

The best countertop is not just attractive. It is harmonious.

This is why Cleveland homeowners appreciate the hands-on design guidance provided by Design Surfaces specialists.

10. Waiting Too Long to Work with Professionals

The earlier you consult an expert, the better your results. Homeowners who wait until the final stage often miss opportunities to coordinate finishes, plan around installation requirements, or select materials that align with their budget.

Professional guidance prevents overspending, minimizes mistakes, and helps you explore options you may not find online.

The right countertop often becomes clear once a professional guides you through the process.

Avoid Mistakes and Choose Countertops with Confidence

The most costly countertop mistake is walking into a showroom believing internet research alone is enough. When you blend your vision with real-world expertise, you get surfaces that are stunning, functional, and designed for the way you live.

Design Surfaces is the trusted source for premium countertops, tile, and stone in Cleveland, and our specialists are ready to help you compare materials, view slabs, explore finishes, and make a confident decision.

Visit the showroom today or contact Design Surfaces to start your project with expert guidance and a beautifully inspired plan.

​​Call: 440.899.9900 • Contact: Submit a Request • Email: info@designsurfaces.com